2005: Detroit Arsenal (8-0-2)
2006: Princeton-56ers (8-0-2)
2007: Princeton-56ers (8-1-1)
2008: St. Paul Twin Stars (record not available)
2009: St. Paul Twin Stars (5-2-1)
2010: Madison 56ers (8-2-0)
2011: Milwaukee Bavarians (8-2-2)
2012: Madison 56ers 2, AFC Cleveland 1
2013: Erie Admirals 1, Quad City Eagles 0
2014: Lansing United 2, Fort Pitt Regiment 1 (AET)
2015: Indiana Fire 3, AFC Cleveland 1
2016: AFC Cleveland 0, Grand Rapids FC 0 (AFC Cleveland wins 3-1 on penalty kicks)
2017: Detroit City FC 3, AFC Ann Arbor 2
2018: Duluth FC 3, AFC Ann Arbor 3 (Duluth FC wins 4-3 on penalty kicks)
2019: Cleveland SC 2, Detroit City FC 2 (Cleveland SC wins 3-2 on penalty kicks)
2020: No competition (COVID-19 pandemic)
2021: Cleveland SC 2, Minneapolis City SC 0
2022: Muskegon Risers 1, Cleveland SC 0
2023: Tulsa Athletic 2, Steel City FC 1
Central Conference champions
2012: Madison 56ers (9-3-0)
2013: Quad City Eagles (9-2-1)
2014: Quad City Eagles (7-1-2)
2015: No conference
2016: Milwaukee Torrent (6-0-0)*
* Central Conference champion not eligible for Midwest Region playoffs
Great Lakes Conference champions
2021: FC Milwaukee Torrent (9-1-0)
2022: Muskegon Risers (8-0-2)
2023: Steel City FC (10-0-2)
2024: Steel City FC 2, Akron City FC 0
Gateway Conference champions
2023: Des Moines United (8-1-1)
2024: Des Moines United 2, FC Milwaukee Torrent 0
Tag(s): History