2009 (charter members)
Tony Ansems, Dan Harris, Willi Wessels, Richard Williams.
2010
Bob Gansler, Jim Launder, Bill Reddan, Ron Holzhueter.
2011
Aldo Santaga, Toby Bares, Rick Kilps, Harry Kelderman, Alex Toth, Sr. (memorial).
2012
Tim Alexander, Sheila Miech, Craig Peltonen, Aleks Nikolic.
2013
Hayden Knight, Dave Scherer, Jerry Panek, Peter Knezic, Laura Moynihan (memorial).
Starting in 2014, the Wisconsin Soccer Coaches Association Hall of Fame joined the Wisconsin Soccer Hall of Fame.