| 1992 |
Division 1 – Milwaukee Marquette 2, Milwaukee Pius 1 |
|
Division 2 – Sheboygan Christian 1, Racine Lutheran 1 (Sheboygan Christian wins on penalty kicks) |
| 1993 |
Division 1 – Milwaukee Pius 1, Milwaukee Marquette 0 |
|
Division 2 – Milwaukee University School 2, Racine Prairie School 0 |
| 1994 |
Division 1 – Milwaukee Marquette 3, Green Bay Notre Dame 0 |
|
Division 2 – Waupun Central Wisconsin Christian 1, Sheboygan Christian 0 |
| 1995 |
Division 1 – Milwaukee Marquette 2, Racine St Catherine's 0 |
|
Division 2 – Milwaukee University School 1, Racine Prairie School 1 (Milwaukee University School wins on penalty kicks) |
| 1996 |
Division 1 – Milwaukee Marquette 4, Racine St Catherine's 2 |
|
Division 2 – Milwaukee University School 1, Racine Prairie School 0 |
| 1997 |
Division 1 – Milwaukee Marquette 2, Racine St Catherine's 0 |
|
Division 2 – Kettle Moraine Lutheran 4, Mount Calvary St. Lawrence 1 |
| 1998 |
Division 1 – Milwaukee Marquette 1, Waukesha Catholic Memorial 0 |
|
Division 2 – Sheboygan Christian 3, Kettle Moraine Lutheran 0 |
| 1999 |
Division 1 – Milwaukee Marquette 1, Waukesha Catholic Memorial 0 |
|
Division 2 – Milwaukee Heritage Christian 2, Oshkosh Christian 0 (OT) |